Fined $811 Million for Scamming Detained Migrants, the Bail Bond Racket Carried On
A company fined $811 million for trapping detained migrants in costly bail contracts kept taking their money under a new name, a BBC investigation has found, leaving families paying thousands of dollars while their relatives stayed locked up.
Libre by Nexus was set up in 2013 by Michael Donovan and Richard Moore, two men who had already served prison sentences for fraud and forgery. It grew into the biggest immigration bail business in the United States, arranging the release of more than 20,000 detained migrants over about a decade and collecting more than $230 million, according to court records.
The firm acted as a go-between: migrants paid it, and it linked them with licensed bondsmen who could post bail. But clients were charged monthly fees that did not count towards their bond, and the terms were hidden from them, the regulator said. The US Consumer Financial Protection Bureau sued, calling it a predatory immigrant-services scam. In 2024 a federal judge agreed, imposed the $811 million penalty and barred the firm from collecting old debts.
The penalty did not end the business. Days after the court order, Donovan sold assets including customer lists and records for $3.50, and the operation resurfaced as Libre Immigration Services. The BBC found the successor company was owned by a convicted fraudster. One client, Mildred Juarez, spent a month in a Texas immigration centre after her friends sent $2,600 to the firm for her bail. The money was never returned, despite repeated promises, and the firm told the BBC it would refund her only once her friend verified their details.
Former staff told the BBC they were instructed to tell callers their money would be repaid once their cases finished, but that never happened. The firm also made released detainees wear ankle bracelets until 2018, former employees said. Moore is now in prison after being convicted of filing fraudulent tax returns for the firm, and he and Donovan, who is also behind bars, await sentencing over insurance fraud and conspiracy. The White House and the Department of Homeland Security did not respond to the BBC's request for comment.
Key points
- A US judge fined Libre by Nexus and its founders $811 million in 2024 after finding it trapped detained migrants in misleading bail contracts.
- The firm helped more than 20,000 migrants out of detention over a decade and took in over $230 million, court records show.
- Days after the ruling, its assets were sold for $3.50 and the business reappeared as Libre Immigration Services, owned by a convicted fraudster.
- Mildred Juarez spent a month in a Texas detention centre after her friends paid $2,600 to the firm; the deposit was never returned.
Photo: Ajay Suresh, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons